Adversarially review an academic draft with independent multi-reviewer rounds, depending on no other skill. It spawns three independent reviewer agents — claim-support, logic/structure, and citation/evidence integrity — each reading only its own prompt and the draft, then writes an Editor Synthesis and re-runs until a round comes back clean. It catches unsupported claims, claims drifted from their evidence tier, interpretation leaking into Results, shallow/append-only revisions, and citations that do not actually support the sentence. Use whenever the user has an EXISTING draft to peer-review or stress-test — this skill reviews a draft, it does NOT write a 综述/review article; if the user has no draft yet and wants a review article written, use research-to-paper-write. Triggers: the user says 审一下这篇草稿, 多轮审, 帮我挑毛病, 查无据claim, 逻辑审一遍, 这篇有没有过度声称, "review my draft", "audit this manuscript", "check for unsupported claims", "is anything overclaimed", "stress-test the argument". Works on a whole paper or a section; called by research-to-paper-write after drafting, or invoked directly on any draft.
Install with
Claude CodeCodexCursorGitHub CopilotGemini CLI
Supported by the Atlas install prompt. Skill-specific requirements vary.
Skill stats
Skills1CategoryScience & researchStars0
About this skill
Adversarially review an academic draft with independent multi-reviewer rounds, depending on no other skill. It spawns three independent reviewer agents — claim-support, logic/structure, and citation/evidence integrity — each reading only its own prompt and the draft, then writes an Editor Synthesis and re-runs until a round comes back clean. It catches unsupported claims, claims drifted from their evidence tier, interpretation leaking into Results, shallow/append-only revisions, and citations that do not actually support the sentence. Use whenever the user has an EXISTING draft to peer-review or stress-test — this skill reviews a draft, it does NOT write a 综述/review article; if the user has no draft yet and wants a review article written, use research-to-paper-write. Triggers: the user says 审一下这篇草稿, 多轮审, 帮我挑毛病, 查无据claim, 逻辑审一遍, 这篇有没有过度声称, "review my draft", "audit this manuscript", "check for unsupported claims", "is anything overclaimed", "stress-test the argument". Works on a whole paper or a section; called by research-to-paper-write after drafting, or invoked directly on any draft.
Quick start
Copy the install prompt. Use the green button above this README.
Send it to your agent. Paste it into your coding agent’s chat and send.
Review the setup. Your agent checks the skill’s instructions, requirements, and installation scope.
Adversarially review an academic draft with independent multi-reviewer rounds, depending on no other skill. It spawns three independent reviewer agents — claim-support, logic/structure, and citation/evidence integrity — each reading only its own prompt and the draft, then writes an Editor Synthesis and re-runs until a round comes back clean. It catches unsupported claims, claims drifted from their evidence tier, interpretation leaking into Results, shallow/append-only revisions, and citations that do not actually support the sentence. Use whenever the user has an EXISTING draft to peer-review or stress-test — this skill reviews a draft, it does NOT write a 综述/review article; if the user has no draft yet and wants a review article written, use research-to-paper-write. Triggers: the user says 审一下这篇草稿, 多轮审, 帮我挑毛病, 查无据claim, 逻辑审一遍, 这篇有没有过度声称, "review my draft", "audit this manuscript", "check for unsupported claims", "is anything overclaimed", "stress-test the argument". Works on a whole paper or a section; called by research-to-paper-write after drafting, or invoked directly on any draft.
About this listing
Category
Science & research
Reported license
MIT
Listing language (estimated)
English
Review status
Not individually reviewed
Agent compatibility
Atlas installation supports Claude Code, Codex, and Cursor. Skill-specific dependencies and features are checked during setup.
Claude Code
Codex
Cursor
GitHub Copilot
Gemini CLI