Back to directory

Light Idea Critique

Agent skill
1 skill

以顶刊/顶会审稿人标准严格判断 idea 是否真有突破,还是常规组合、套壳、概念堆叠、缺乏理论深度或实验支撑。当用户问"这个 idea 行不行/够不够创新/帮我挑刺",或 m03 产出 idea 后必须使用。先盲后明立标准、八维度加权打分、五视角对抗、反谄媚硬协议,给判决 + Revision Roadmap,引导回 m03。

Install with
Claude CodeCodexCursorGitHub CopilotGemini CLI

Supported by the Atlas install prompt. Skill-specific requirements vary.

Skill stats

Skills1CategoryProduct & designStars0

About this skill

以顶刊/顶会审稿人标准严格判断 idea 是否真有突破,还是常规组合、套壳、概念堆叠、缺乏理论深度或实验支撑。当用户问"这个 idea 行不行/够不够创新/帮我挑刺",或 m03 产出 idea 后必须使用。先盲后明立标准、八维度加权打分、五视角对抗、反谄媚硬协议,给判决 + Revision Roadmap,引导回 m03。

Quick start

  1. Copy the install prompt. Use the green button above this README.
  2. Send it to your agent. Paste it into your coding agent’s chat and send.
  3. Review the setup. Your agent checks the skill’s instructions, requirements, and installation scope.
Review, license & listing details
Review the source before using this skill

This is an imported listing. We haven’t certified its safety, license, or compatibility. Skills may include executable scripts.

Automated security scan: Partial

Only SKILL.md was scanned. Supporting files and scripts were not checked. No safety grade has been assigned.

0 potential findings · Scanned 11/4/2026 · Scanner 0.2.1

Content SHA-256: 1ef2a2c19d3ac7f6913754a328c1a8a124f5e01aa69f1316d91d7520e5bb8bcc

About scan coverage and limitations

About this listing

Category
Product & design
Reported license
MIT
Listing language (estimated)
Chinese
Review status
Not individually reviewed
Agent compatibility
Atlas installation supports Claude Code, Codex, and Cursor. Skill-specific dependencies and features are checked during setup.