Reviewer Response | Agent Skills Atlas

About this skill

Draft a rigorous, polite, point-by-point response to reviewer comments on a journal or conference submission (R1 / R2 / R3 letters), plus the corresponding manuscript revisions. Categorizes each comment as concession / pushback / clarification needed / minor fix, drafts the response and the revision for each, and assembles a cover letter. Composes with peer-review (consume comments from a review output) and manuscript-drafter (revise prose using the manuscript's voice profile and academic register rules). Won't concede a point the data doesn't support; preserves framing where the reviewer misread; addresses every point. Trigger when: user mentions "respond to reviewers", "R1 response", "R2 response", "rebuttal", "address reviewer comments", "reviewer-response letter", "point-by-point response", "revision and resubmission", "response to reviewer 2", "cover letter to editor", or runs /respond.

Quick start

Copy the install prompt. Use the green button above this README.
Send it to your agent. Paste it into your coding agent’s chat and send.
Review the setup. Your agent checks the skill’s instructions, requirements, and installation scope.

Installation guide →

Review, license & listing details

Review the source before using this skill

This is an imported listing. We haven’t certified its safety, license, or compatibility. Skills may include executable scripts.

Automated security scan: Partial

Only SKILL.md was scanned. Supporting files and scripts were not checked. No safety grade has been assigned.

0 potential findings · Scanned 11/4/2026 · Scanner 0.2.1

Content SHA-256: 1e111cbc3afbad9ea516f797b018f246994f6220b2b6cb68f47584dbf8bdec6b

About scan coverage and limitations

Original listing metadata

Original name

reviewer-response

Original description

Draft a rigorous, polite, point-by-point response to reviewer comments on a journal or conference submission (R1 / R2 / R3 letters), plus the corresponding manuscript revisions. Categorizes each comment as concession / pushback / clarification needed / minor fix, drafts the response and the revision for each, and assembles a cover letter. Composes with `peer-review` (consume comments from a review output) and `manuscript-drafter` (revise prose using the manuscript's voice profile and academic register rules). Won't concede a point the data doesn't support; preserves framing where the reviewer misread; addresses every point. Trigger when: user mentions "respond to reviewers", "R1 response", "R2 response", "rebuttal", "address reviewer comments", "reviewer-response letter", "point-by-point response", "revision and resubmission", "response to reviewer 2", "cover letter to editor", or runs /respond.

About this listing

Category: Content & writing
Reported license: MIT
Listing language (estimated): English
Review status: Not individually reviewed
Agent compatibility: Atlas installation supports Claude Code, Codex, and Cursor. Skill-specific dependencies and features are checked during setup.