AGENT SKILLS ATLASArguing Research Papers
Argue ONE FINISHED written research claim to an absent reviewer, or critically appraise ONE paper's argument, method, and validity. Owns claim calibration, contribution/novelty positioning, warrants, qualifiers, anti-fabrication, reviewer red-team, and rebuttal. Use for paper argument / contribution / “not novel” / overclaim / reviewer 2 / peer-review critique / 論文の主張 / 貢献 / 新規性 / 査読 / リバッタル. Cuts: fact extract → raising-resolution; neutral one-paper summary → direct answer with its citation gate silent; corpus state → systematizing-knowledge; premise-only excavation → surfacing-blind-spots; section order/MECE → structuring-documents; wording → linting-prose; live talk → designing-presentations; program reopen → directing-research; thesis genesis → forging-novel-theses; expensive/irreversible one-tree → acting-on-hypotheses; cheap reversible probe → domain/plain executor; agent topology → orchestrating-agents. Claim/calibration stay SOLO. English skill; answer in the user's language.
Skill stats
Skills1CategoryScience & researchStars0
About this skill
Argue ONE FINISHED written research claim to an absent reviewer, or critically appraise ONE paper's argument, method, and validity. Owns claim calibration, contribution/novelty positioning, warrants, qualifiers, anti-fabrication, reviewer red-team, and rebuttal. Use for paper argument / contribution / “not novel” / overclaim / reviewer 2 / peer-review critique / 論文の主張 / 貢献 / 新規性 / 査読 / リバッタル. Cuts: fact extract → raising-resolution; neutral one-paper summary → direct answer with its citation gate silent; corpus state → systematizing-knowledge; premise-only excavation → surfacing-blind-spots; section order/MECE → structuring-documents; wording → linting-prose; live talk → designing-presentations; program reopen → directing-research; thesis genesis → forging-novel-theses; expensive/irreversible one-tree → acting-on-hypotheses; cheap reversible probe → domain/plain executor; agent topology → orchestrating-agents. Claim/calibration stay SOLO. English skill; answer in the user's language.
Quick start
- Copy the install prompt. Use the green button above this README.
- Send it to your agent. Paste it into your coding agent’s chat and send.
- Review the setup. Your agent checks the skill’s instructions, requirements, and installation scope.
Installation guide →
Review, license & listing details
Review the source before using this skillThis is an imported listing. We haven’t certified its safety, license, or compatibility. Skills may include executable scripts.
Automated security scan: PartialOnly SKILL.md was scanned. Supporting files and scripts were not checked. No safety grade has been assigned.
0 potential findings · Scanned 11/4/2026 · Scanner 0.2.1
Content SHA-256: c1da0dbd1be03a96f448939ace953b839685cec544d266a6d783d48f3df14c39
About scan coverage and limitations Original listing metadata
Original name
arguing-research-papersOriginal description
Argue ONE FINISHED written research claim to an absent reviewer, or critically appraise ONE paper's argument, method, and validity. Owns claim calibration, contribution/novelty positioning, warrants, qualifiers, anti-fabrication, reviewer red-team, and rebuttal. Use for paper argument / contribution / “not novel” / overclaim / reviewer 2 / peer-review critique / 論文の主張 / 貢献 / 新規性 / 査読 / リバッタル. Cuts: fact extract → raising-resolution; neutral one-paper summary → direct answer with its citation gate silent; corpus state → systematizing-knowledge; premise-only excavation → surfacing-blind-spots; section order/MECE → structuring-documents; wording → linting-prose; live talk → designing-presentations; program reopen → directing-research; thesis genesis → forging-novel-theses; expensive/irreversible one-tree → acting-on-hypotheses; cheap reversible probe → domain/plain executor; agent topology → orchestrating-agents. Claim/calibration stay SOLO. English skill; answer in the user's language.
About this listing
- Category
- Science & research
- Reported license
- Not specified
- Listing language (estimated)
- English
- Review status
- Not individually reviewed
- Agent compatibility
- Atlas installation supports Claude Code, Codex, and Cursor. Skill-specific dependencies and features are checked during setup.
Claude Code
Codex
Cursor
GitHub Copilot
Gemini CLI